Skip to main content

Considerations for Human Subjects Research (IRB)

1. Do I need an approved IRB protocol to administer surveys through masder.net?

If you are using the data for your own personal use, you likely do not need IRB approval. However, it is the responsibility of each account owner to determine whether it is needed or not. You can use the MASDER website for data collection regardless of whether your project is considered Human Subjects Research (HSR).

As the MASDER account holder, you are responsible for determining if your project meets the criteria for HSR and therefore needs IRB approval. You should either have IRB approval, or you should have verification that your project is not Human Subjects Research (HSR).

If your project is HSR, you are responsible for gaining approval through your authorizing institution and ensuring you have followed appropriate protocols regarding consent, etc. MASDER does not take responsibility for your IRB approval or check the status of your IRB compliance.

2. Can I add my own consent form on the survey?

Yes! You can add a custom consent question to the beginning of your MASDER survey. This option allows you to enter your own consent language and edit two multiple choice response options for either giving or declining consent. If you use this option, please note that survey respondents who decline to consent will not be shown the survey and will be redirected to the final Thank You page.

3. Does MASDER have IRB approval?

Yes. The MASDER project and website have been declared Exempt by the Villanova University IRB, and prior data was collected and managed under the California State University Monterey Bay IRB. If you need documentation of the approved IRB status, please contact MASDER. This IRB protocol approves the MASDER team for website development, data collection, cleaning, and reporting.

Each survey administered through the MASDER website has a MASDER consent form at the beginning. This form asks respondents to consent to their data being used as part of the MASDER research project. Consenting to MASDER allows us to include data in our national sample, which appears in comparison reports for each class. It also allows the data to be included in our de-identified national database and allows the MASDER team to study the data. If a respondent doe not consent to MASDER research, they are still able to complete each survey, but their data will be excluded from the national sample in reports, the national database, and further analysis. In summary, whether or not a respondent consents to MASDER does not affect their ability to complete any surveys; it simply determines if their data will be included in the broader MASDER research study.

 

The following text might be useful in submitting your own IRB protocol when using masder.net to administer surveys.

Description of MASDER.net

  • MASDER.net is an attitudinal survey data collection platform created as part of the NSF-funded MASDER research project (DUE-2013392). This website facilitates the administration of six different survey instruments around statistics and data science college-level student and instruct attitudes, as well as inventories of the classroom learning environment. 
     
  • Each survey administered through the MASDER website has a MASDER consent form at the beginning. This form asks respondents to consent to their data being used as part of the MASDER research project. Consenting to MASDER allows us to include data in our national sample, which appears in comparison reports for each class. It also allows the data to be included in our de-identified national database and allows the MASDER team to study the data. If a respondent does not consent to MASDER research, they are still able to complete each survey, but their data will be excluded from the national sample in reports, the national database, and further analysis. In summary, whether or not a respondent consents to MASDER does not affect their ability to complete any surveys; it simply determines if their data will be included in the broader MASDER research study.
     
  • Surveys also have a customization feature that allows instructors to add their own consent form prior to the MASDER consent form. This allows the MASDER research study to be treated separately from an instructor's own research study.
     
  • The MASDER data management process includes the automated creation of a report comparing an instructor's class to MASDER's national sample. This report is a large motivating factor for why instructors choose to use the platform, since they are able to see a comparison of their own student to a national sample. this report is fully de-identified and shows only aggregated course data. Students are only included in the national sample if they have consented to the MASDER research study. A preview of the Shiny app report can be seen here.

Identifiable Data

  • MASDER survey data is not anonymous. On student surveys, we require collection of student first name and last name, and email address. These fields allow us to match pre/post survey responses, and return identifiable data to instructors to use to assign credit for survey completion, etc. Therefore, on your IRB protocol, make sure to say the data are identifiable, not anonymous.
     
  • We ask for the student information before showing consent forms. This means that even if a student declines to consent and does not complete the survey, your data will have a record of the student name and email address whether or not they consented.

Data Storage

  • Data is collected via Qaultrics (specifically, Qualtrics through Winona State University) and is stored in the Qualtrics system. Data is passed via Qualtrics API to the Amazon Web Services (AWS) server for automated data management to facilitate the data download and creation of reports.
     
  • Csv files of raw data are accessible by the instructor when they are logged into masder.net. These files are stored on the AWS server.
     
  • Fully de-identified data is also stored in a Shiny app on the AWS server for the purposes of creating the instructor report.
     
  • There is no plan to destroy data, as it is part of the national data used in reporting and will be collected cumulatively throughout the entirety of website operation.

MASDER Consent Forms and IRB Documentation

MASDER surveys include a consent form giving the team access to manage the data collection process and use for our research purposes. 

Student Consent Form 

Instructor Consent Form

EPIC Consent Form

 

MASDER.net was originally approved and developed under California State University Monterey Bay's IRB as Exempt-level research. Post-grant, the website has moved under the supervision of Villanova University and is approved as Exempt-level research. This IRB protocol approves the MASDER team for website development, data collection, cleaning, and reporting.

Villanova IRB Protocol

Privacy Policies

  • The MASDER website is powered by Drupal because Drupal is the standard for secure, account-based website access.
     
  • Privacy is generally governed by the IRB protocol at Villanova University. Only the approved researchers on the MASDER protocol have access to data collected on masder.net. The masder.net account holder will only have access to students data collected via their own account and survey administration links.
     
  • The MASDER study investigators may grant access to approved researchers to use identifiable data for validated studies after a Data Use Agreement has been signed between Villanova University and their own institution.
     
  • For students that have specifically consented to the MASDER research consent form, full de-identified data will eventually be shared publicly via R and/or Python apps.